About three weeks ago I finished the Ragamuffin Gospel by Brennan Manning. This is an older book that has been around since 1990 but has more recently been relaunched.
I have not reviewed this book until now as I wanted to think about what I would say. This is because there are some stinging critiques of Manning and this book. Some have called what Manning says heresy, which is a very strong criticism. Others have pointed to his life, with its many faults (Manning is/was an alcoholic, divorcee, etc.). Yet others have critiqued his theology.
If you chose to read this book, I advise you to check out some of what is written. A simple internet search will turn up a lot of entries. In reading these critiques however, I encourage you to expose them to some academic rigour. For instance, many of the critiques take very small sections of his book out of context. Some leave key words out. Just as when you study a verse in the bible, it is strongly advisable to read around the section. As what is his point? What is the chapter about? What does Manning mean by that word or phrase?
So, be discerning!!!
I personally conclude that much of the criticism is unloving, picky, academically unsound rubbish. There are a couple of areas where I believe Manning's theology is wrong. However they are not die in the ditch issues. The one I really have an issue with is on pg168 where he gets into Carl Jung's self acceptance philosophy. I disagree with this.
I have two other issues with the book:
1... It is not easy to read. Many other books of this genre have a much easier flow but are no less challenging.
2... I dislike the term ragamuffin. I know... silly eh!
With all the criticism out of the way, I enjoyed reading this book. While Manning may not be easy to read, he is a powerful writer with an idea that resonates with many in my generation. His story in Chpt 7 about a recovering alcoholic was tear jerking.
You will find this book 'preaches" a similar message to many of the other books I have read recently. A message of sacrificial loving and a desire to flee from self-serving judging.
I see this as the heart of Jesus' teaching. Repent from your sins and love others. You could say this is LOVE GOD, LOVE OTHERS as sinning is turning your back on God.
I would encourage you to read this book. I would also encourage you to be discerning (sift out the junk - ie. read the Gospel of Luke and see what gets caught). In otherwords, do what you in everyday life... observe, pray, ponder, discern, implement.
